Clamping cars in hospital carparks is immoral – Naughten

In Health, News by Denis Naughten

Pay & display parking must be banned at hospitals


The pay & display car parking and clamping policy at hospitals like James Connolly in Blanchardstown & Portiuncula Hospital, Ballinasloe, must be urgently reviewed as patients are being forced to rush out of A&E in fear of being clamped, says Denis Naughten.

“While I believe that patients, carers and next of kin should not be charged parking fees at all at hospitals, the policy at James Connolly & Portiuncula Hospitals where there is a clamping in place is totally unacceptable,” stated Denis Naughten.

“In most hospitals motorists pay for the time that they were in the hospital when they are about to exit. However, in James Connolly & Portiuncula there is a pay & display system which leaves people guessing how long they will be before they go into the hospital.

“How could anybody going into A&E at present have any idea how long they are going to be and therefore how long they will need a parking ticket for with the current level of over-crowding?

“In such situations people are paying for two hours but then having to rush out, sometimes with a sick child, to get another ticket because of the fear that they will be clamped. Nobody who has experienced a long wait in A&E with a sick relative or child should be in a situation where they have to worry about being clamped when they go back to their car.”

Referring to a proposal to cap hospital parking at €10 per day, Denis Naughten stated: “Patients and their carers should not be expected to pay for parking, especially when you consider that quite often this would be on top of a €100 fee to attend A&E while in some cases this could result in bills of €300 for patients who must attend hospital five days a week for six weeks to receive treatment.

“The whole system of car parking charges at our hospitals needs to be overhauled. Patients, their carers, those providing transport to appointments and next of kin such as the parent of a sick child should never have to pay for parking in any of our hospitals and we must introduce an outright ban on clamping in hospital carparks,” concluded Denis Naughten.